| Rank | Hitters | Pitchers |
|---|---|---|
| 10 | Ian Desmond | John Lannan |
| 11 | Derek Norris | Garrett Mock |
| 12 | Josh Whitesell | Brad Peacock |
| 13 | Matt Whitney | Brad Meyers |
| 14 | Garrett Guzman | Jhonny Nunez |
| 15 | Roger Bernadina | Zech Zinicola |
| 16 | Kory Casto | Marco Estrada |
| 17 | Andrew Lefave | Adrian Alaniz |
| 18 | Leonard Davis | Cory VanAllen |
| 19 | Dani Arias | Martin Beno |
| 20 | Bill Rhinehart | Hassan Pena |
| 21 | Mark Gildea | Yader Peralta |
| 22 | Aaron Seuss | PJ Dean |
| 23 | Edgardo Baez | Federico Tanco |
| 24 | Garrett Bass | Jack Spradlin |
| 25 | Alejandro Hodge | Marcos Frias |
| Francisco Soriano | Juan Jaime | |
| Yeurys Tejeda |
My choice for the #10 hitter is likely to generate some debate. Ian Desmond was a 2004 3rd round draft pick by the Montreal Expos out of a Florida high school. Most people remember Desmond primarily from his performance in one game against the Orioles during the Nationals first spring training as Washington’s team. That was likely the worst thing that could have happened to him because he was immediately portrayed as “the next Derek Jeter.” Desmond is not the next Jeter, but he remains a prospect worth watching. He was rushed to Double-A in 2006 (184/221/232) which added to the delay in his development and it seemed to have lingered when he was demoted to Potomac part way through the 2006 season (244/313/384). He spent the entire 2007 season in the Carolina League where he started to turn the corner. After a slow start (239/339/380), he picked up in the second half (286/372/478). The biggest thing to look at for Desmond was his age in 2007, he was 21 which is right in line for expectations of the Carolina League. Scouts have commented that his plate discipline/pitch recognition improved significantly last season. But the strongest part of Desmond’s resume is his glove. He makes the spectacular play almost with ease. His challenge was always his focus on the routine play which also appeared to improve as the 2007 season wore on. He should be in Harrisburg in 2008 and if he can build on his strong second half, Desmond still has the opportunity to compete for the shortstop role in Washington in 2009 (when Cristian Guzman’s contract has expired).
John Lannan was the biggest surprise of the 2007 season. The 2005 11th round selection by the Nationals skyrocketed from Potomac to the majors in less than a season. The lefty is a finesse pitcher who relies on two fastballs, a change and a curve. He is never going to strike out a ton of hitters and will have to rely on his defense to help him. His ceiling is as a #4 starter but that should be just fine for the Nationals who are likely to give him every opportunity to compete for a spot in the big league rotation in 2008. I think he’ll be a victim of the numbers game and begin his 2008 in Triple-A Columbus.
Positively Half St. | 18-Feb-08 at 10:53 am | Permalink
I’m curious about in which direction you think the controversy of a #10 rating for Ian Desmond will trend. Will folks think it is too high, or too low?
Personally, I gave up on Desmond after his bad 2006, which shows why I am not a scout. Even still, I will be shocked if he improves to become a major-league player. What I keep forgetting, though, is how young he is.
Louis J. | 18-Feb-08 at 12:31 pm | Permalink
Brian
I like Desmond. He has a lot of talent and is a fan favorite. The second half of 2007 at Potomac showed much improvement. The only things Desmond needs are: an off season of tutoring at Barry Larkin house (everybody else has been there) and the development of a Tiger Woods’ work ethic, seriousness and competitive drive to succeed. He has too much fun!
Tulsa Fan | 18-Feb-08 at 1:01 pm | Permalink
Desmond should be an interesting story to follow to see if he can build on his 2nd half success of last year or goes back to struggling again. Especially so since the organization will be needing a SS soon, well really they’ve needed one for the last few years, and the overall lack of talent at the position in the system.
VladiHondo | 18-Feb-08 at 1:52 pm | Permalink
Desmond’s 2006 dropoff was Boone’s fault, after saying that spring they wouldn’t promote unless a player “earned” it, he started him at AA not based on Desmond’s .247/.291/.334 at Savannah and not much better numbers at Potomac (.256/.325/.385).
When he was at H’burg, both Ian and Kory Casto put in LOTS of extra time with the hitting coach, but he was just in over his head as a 20 yr old in AA.
Glad he turned it around and hope it continues, I’m rooting for him.
VladiHondo | 18-Feb-08 at 1:57 pm | Permalink
Oh yeah! The controversy!! Another one is I think it’s people now think Smiley Gonzalez will end up a 2b, but I’m not sure Smiley (another great kid!) should grade out much higher than Ian as a hitter, definitely lower as a fielder.
Wonder also how Smiley and Stephen King will compare since both may now second-sackers.
Thanks for the list Brian!
Bob Lowry | 18-Feb-08 at 4:10 pm | Permalink
Its amazing how much stronger the starting pitching rotation is this year compared to last season. Although Lannon is labled as a prospective #5 pitcher this season in the Nats rotation, you have ranked nine other pitching prospects ahead of him going into this season.
It will be important for these young pitchers to pitch regularly in the minors to prepare for when the reach the majors, although I suspect that Detwiler, Mock, Balester, Clippard along with Lannon will be pushing for a spot in DC in the next couple of seasons. Then there is a second wave just behind them of McCreary, Smoker and the Vermont contingent pushing these guys. I’m certain they are the reasons why the Nats did not want to tie themselves to Livan Hernandez this year. The probabilities are that some will produce in the majors and others won’t but the sheer strength in numbers is encouraging.
Louis J. | 19-Feb-08 at 8:18 am | Permalink
Brian
Sorry to digress, Nats’ fans should follow the money (and player options) for the starting rotation “favorites”: Tim Redding ($1M salary & 0 options), John Patterson ($850,000 & 0 options), Shawn Hill (0 options) and Jason Bergmann (0 options) are the top four favorites. Chico, Clippard, Hanrahan & Lannan (all have 2 options) are competing for the No. 5 spot. But, if the Nats sign free agent LHP Odalis Perez, he moves into the rotation and Chico, Clippard, Hanrahan & Lannan move to AAA.
Phillip | 19-Feb-08 at 12:31 pm | Permalink
Brian,
I may be ahead of myself here but I’m wondering if Adam Carr will make the list since he’s the only hard thrower in the system?